The Longest Underground River in the United States
There are technically two contenders for the longest underground river in the United States: one is the Lost River in Indiana, and the other is the Myst'ry River, also in Indiana. The difference is that while Lost River is said to be larger, it has never been fully explored, but the confirmed largest navigable underground river in the United States thus far belongs to the Myst'ry River, so for clarity's sake, the latter will be the focus, as the former is still unknown and mostly unexplored.
History

The Myst'ry River is actually part of Bluespring Caverns in Lawrence County, Indiana. The local legend suggests that the cave system was actually discovered in the 1800s, and there was once an entrance to the caverns that fed water into the nearby White River, but a dam built in 1913 effectively destroyed the original entrance. 27 years later (in 1940), a wicked storm created a new opening. During the storm, a small pond on the Colglazier farm was swallowed up by the Earth, revealing a myriad of caves and complex caverns underneath, as well as what would come to be known as the Myst'ry River. The discovery eventually drew national attention, and the rest is history.
A Strange World...

A cavern's ecosystem is a strange world, and Bluespring's Myst'ry River is no different. The caverns are 100 to 400 ft (30 m to 122 m) below the surface and approximately 21 miles (34 km) long, while the Myst'ry River is 3 miles (4.8 km) of quiet darkness. Year-round, the temperature is at a cool 53° Fahrenheit (12°C), and bats are known to sleep in the caves during winter. The real strangeness, however, is in the other exotic lifeforms that call the Myst'ry River home: there are rare Northern Cavefish as well as blind crayfish and various types of beetles, crickets, and salamanders that scurry on the cave walls. Many of the cave's creatures are blind and translucent because they do not need pigmentation to protect against UV exposure, making them white and nearly invisible.
It's these oddities of Bluespring's that have helped to make it a landmark in Indiana and also a local legend, but perhaps the greatest allure is the Myst'ry River itself.
A Subterranean Legend
Part of the mystique of the very aptly named Myst'ry River is its size. There are, of course, longer underground rivers like the Lost River. The problem with those, however, is that they are barely explorable and are thus subject to guess work when it comes to their size and continuity. Why Myst'ry River is different is because 3 miles (4.8 km) of navigability is incredibly rare in an underground environment. The tour itself would go on for too long if all three miles were to be sailed. Most underground rivers are like the River of Styx at Oregon Caves National Monument and Preserve: they are typically less than a mile long (0.4 miles or 0.6 km in Styx's case), they disappear into the ground, they tend to vanish with the seasons, and they are thin like streams rather than full rivers. Hence the problem of navigability: if a boat can't fit, it isn't navigable.
The legend of Myst'ry River is that it very much is like a wide and explorable river on the surface but otherwise inhabits a radically different space. And it is that strange world and ease of access to this subterranean rarity that makes people want to explore it.
Taking a Tour
The Myst'ry River no doubt is the crowning jewel of the caverns, and that is why there are boat tours that explore parts of the river daily. The caverns are usually open daily from mid-March through October, though area flooding occasionally cancels tours. From 9am to 5pm, guests are seated on flat-bottomed boats that seat up to 17 people at a time for an hour-long river tour that covers 1.2 miles (2 km) of that alien world. There is no strict dress code, and cave wear is not required, but open-toed shoes are discouraged, and a light jacket is recommended.
Fitting for the tour and all it offers, Bluespring Caverns and the Myst'ry River bring tourists from around the nation each year. And with the boats running daily, it is never quite too late to see the longest navigable underground river in the United States.