Aerial photo over Canandaigua City Pier, New York

The Towns In The Finger Lakes Where Retirees Are Moving To

Livingston County's 65-and-older population grew 20.5% from July 2020 to July 2026, according to Medicare enrollment, the fastest gain in the Finger Lakes. Wayne County followed at 18.5% and Ontario County at 17.3%, both ahead of the 15.3% statewide gain. The movement runs outward from Monroe County, east along the Erie Canal and the Lake Ontario shore and south into Livingston County. As of September 2026, typical home values in those three counties range from about $248,000 to $324,000, against roughly $525,000 statewide. Closer to the heart of the lakes, Seneca, Schuyler, and Steuben counties all trail the state.

Geneseo

The boat dock at Long Point Park on Conesus Lake in Geneseo, New York
The dock at Long Point Park on Conesus Lake in Geneseo, New York.

Livingston County added older residents faster than all but two counties in New York, and its Medicare enrollment among seniors climbed 20.5% in six years. In the town of Geneseo, the 65-plus population grew from 1,309 to 1,527 between the 2015 to 2019 and 2020 to 2024 Census surveys. The 16.7% rise beat the 13.0% statewide gain. Every recent older newcomer counted in the survey arrived from another New York county. Internal Revenue Service (IRS) migration data for 2022 to 2023 show Monroe County sending Livingston more new residents than any other county.

Main Street still keeps Emmeline, the bronze bear that first took its place atop the village fountain in 1888. On Conesus Lake, the town's Long Point Park runs a seasonal beach with a public dock, gazebos, and gardens. The National Warplane Museum on Big Tree Lane books rides in its World War II aircraft. The museum has scheduled its next Geneseo Airshow, billed as "The Greatest Show on Turf," for July 10 and 11, 2027.

Pittsford

The Erie Canal passing through the village of Pittsford, New York
The Erie Canal passes through the village of Pittsford, New York.

Along the Erie Canal in Monroe County, Pittsford's 65-plus population rose 20.8%, from 5,708 to 6,895, well ahead of the state's 13.0%. About 1.6% of its seniors arrived from another county or state in the year before the survey, just above the 1.45% statewide rate. Most of those 112 newcomers were New Yorkers. Countywide, Monroe's Medicare enrollment among seniors grew 14.8%, slightly under the state's 15.3%.

The canal sets the pace in the village. Shops, cafes, and restaurants now fill Schoen Place, a restored 19th-century warehouse district beside the water. The Sam Patch tour boat leaves from there for 90-minute narrated cruises through Lock 32. Back on land, the town's senior program at the Pittsford Community Center on Lincoln Avenue runs Lunch Club 60 on Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays. Its fitness classes, from tai chi to Zumba Gold, cost residents nothing. Twice a month, a Tuesday luncheon ends with a guest presentation, and guests can stay on for cards and games.

Webster

Webster Town Hall
Webster Town Hall. Image credit: DanielPenfield, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Monroe County's town of Webster runs north to the Lake Ontario shore. Its senior count climbed 16.6%, from 9,096 to 10,607, outpacing the 13.0% statewide gain. Recent movers make up about 1.6% of its seniors, a hair above New York's 1.45%, and 62 of those 167 came from another state.

Webster Park covers 550 acres of lakeshore slopes and valleys, with a fishing pier and five marked trails totaling about 4.9 miles. The town's Hojack Trail follows an old rail bed for 4.95 miles, from Lake Road to Phillips Road. Inland, the Webster Recreation Center on Chiyoda Drive serves Lunch Club 60 every weekday at noon. Its free Talks on Tuesdays have covered scams and fall prevention. A bus picks up residents 55 and older on Mondays, Tuesdays, and Thursdays for $2 round trip, and the Thursday ride home includes a grocery stop.

Ontario

 North Ontario Methodist Church, Brick Church Corners, Ontario, NY
North Ontario Methodist Church, Brick Church Corners, Ontario, NY. Image credit: Lvklock, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Iron ore paid the bills in the Wayne County town of Ontario for about a century after its discovery in 1811. Later, the mines turned to paint pigment, including the red used on barns. The Ontario Historical Society keeps that story alive at its Heritage Square Museum. Its Baptist Meeting House shows ore-mining artifacts, and the grounds hold an ore miner's house and a log cabin. Today, the town's senior count is the growth story. It rose 38.5% across the two Census surveys, nearly triple the state's pace, from 1,719 to 2,381. Wayne County ranked eighth among New York's 62 counties for Medicare growth among seniors, at 18.5%. Monroe County supplied nearly half of Wayne's newcomers from elsewhere in the state.

On the lakeshore, Bear Creek & Thompson Park sits at the harbor on Lake Road. The park keeps a boat launch and a large grassy area along the lakeshore. Inland, Casey Park on Knickerbocker Road adds a canoe and kayak launch, nature walks, and lifeguarded swimming in season. Casey Park stays open year-round from 9 am to dusk.

Macedon

{"embedUrl":"https://www.instagram.com/p/C-K4xb5I6Tk/embed/"}

Between the two Census surveys, Macedon's 65-plus population jumped 42.9%, more than three times the state's rate. In this Wayne County town, the count rose from 1,435 to 2,051. All 38 of its newest older residents were New Yorkers from other counties. Recent arrivals equal 1.9% of the town's older residents, above the 1.45% state rate.

Macedon village keeps its historical marker at Lock 30 on the Erie Canal. Older canal history survives nearby. On Quaker Road, a marker stands at Lock 60. The lock dates to 1821, when it was Lock 71 on Clinton's Ditch, the original canal. Crews rebuilt it in 1841 during the canal's enlargement. Nearby, part of old Lock 61 and a stretch of the enlarged canal now serve as Lock 30's spillway. From May through October, Long Acre Farms on Eddy Road pairs a farm market and ice cream shop with a tasting room at JD Wine Cellars.

Palmyra

Aerial view of the village of Palmyra, New York
Aerial view of the village of Palmyra, New York. Editorial credit: Shutterstock.com

No town in the Finger Lakes counties drew recent older arrivals at a higher rate than Palmyra. Newcomers account for about 9.0% of its seniors, roughly six times the state rate. Of those 150 newcomers, 127 moved from another state. The senior count grew 17.4%, from 1,423 to 1,670, against 13.0% statewide. IRS data show the South supplied more than half of Wayne County's out-of-state newcomers.

Palmyra, another Wayne County town, keeps its history in five museums run by Historic Palmyra. The Palmyra Historical Museum houses a research collection covering the Civil War, the Erie Canal, and medical history. Visitors with a narrower interest can pick between the Erie Canal Depot, the Print Shop Museum, and the Alling Coverlet Museum.

Victor

Ganondagan State Historic Site in Victor, New York
Ganondagan State Historic Site in Victor, New York. Editorial Photo Credit: Zack Frank via Shutterstock.

Older movers from other New York counties reach Victor at five times New York's rate. Recent arrivals make up 7.3% of residents in that age group, and 238 of those 263 newcomers moved from elsewhere in the state. The 65-plus population rose 27.4%, from 2,820 to 3,592, about twice the state's pace. In Ontario County, home to Victor, senior Medicare rolls grew 17.3%, ahead of the state's 15.3%. Monroe County was the county's leading source of new residents.

Ganondagan State Historic Site, a National Historic Landmark, covers 569 acres where a 17th-century Seneca town once stood. Its Seneca Art & Culture Center opens Wednesday through Saturday. A full-size bark longhouse, furnished as a Seneca family home of the late 1600s, opens from May through October. Closer to the village, the Victor Hiking Trails group meets every Wednesday at 9 am at the Victor Farmington Library on West Main Street.

Canandaigua

Boats docked on Canandaigua Lake in Canandaigua, New York
Boats docked on Canandaigua Lake in Canandaigua, New York. Editorial credit: PQK / Shutterstock.com

Canandaigua wraps the north end of Canandaigua Lake, and most of its newest older residents come from other states. Out-of-state movers account for 46 of the city's 67 recent older arrivals. Across Ontario County, the city's home county, the South sent close to half of all newcomers from other states. The city's senior count rose 15.2%, from 2,363 to 2,722, ahead of the 13.0% statewide gain.

Kershaw Park stretches along the shore on land made by filling part of the lake between 1932 and 1936. A 1996 lakefront expansion added 3.5 acres of beachfront. Downtown, the Salvation Army Senior Lounge on Saltonstall Street keeps drop-in hours weekdays from 9 am to 3 pm. F.F. Thompson Hospital, part of UR Medicine, treats patients on Parrish Street. Its parent, Thompson Health, also runs Ferris Hills at West Lake, an independent and enriched senior living community on 57 wooded acres with views of the lake.

Seneca

Street view in Seneca, NY
Street view in Seneca, NY. Image credit: Andre Carrotflower, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The Ontario Pathways rail trail stretches about 11.5 miles from Canandaigua to the hamlet of Stanley, in the Ontario County town of Seneca. Farming still leads the local economy, with cabbage, corn, and beans in the fields and large dairy barns across the town. All 25 older newcomers counted in Seneca moved from another state, equal to 4.3% of the town's 65-plus residents and triple the state rate. The 65-plus count climbed 20.9%, from 484 to 585, well above the state's 13.0%.

Roadside farm stands sell produce most days, often on the honor system. In Stanley, Wickham's Pick'n Patch opens its pumpkin fields and corn maze each fall. The hamlet of Seneca Castle claims a place in farm history as the birthplace of the first mechanized cabbage harvester.

Manchester

Manchester, New York
Manchester, New York. Image credit: Mmrvideo, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The Ontario County town of Manchester holds three villages: Manchester, Shortsville, and Clifton Springs. Across the town, the number of residents 65 and older grew 14.1%, from 1,856 to 2,117, ahead of the state's 13.0%. Of the 34 recent older arrivals, 22 came from other New York counties and 12 from another state.

Clifton Springs made its name with Dr. Henry Foster's water cure, which he built on the mineral water of Sulphur Brook in 1850. That enterprise became today's Clifton Springs Hospital & Clinic, part of Rochester Regional Health. In 1974, the old 1896 sanitarium building reopened as the Spa Apartments, a senior residence. The Foster Cottage Museum tells the story of the water cure from the doctor's 1854 Victorian home. For a walk, the 1.5-mile Manchester Gateway Trail follows the Canandaigua Outlet.

Where The Senior Gain Is Heading

Senior growth in the Finger Lakes is running strongest in the towns that face Monroe County, while Seneca, Schuyler, and Steuben counties trail the state. As of September 2026, Wayne County's typical home value sat near $253,000 and Ontario County's near $324,000, both far below New York's $525,000. Ontario County, home to the hospitals in Canandaigua and Clifton Springs, ranked 16th of 62 counties for Medicare growth among residents 65 and older. Palmyra's 127 and Webster's 62 older arrivals from other states show that the pull reaches well beyond New York.

Share
  1. Home
  2. Places
  3. Cities
  4. The Towns In The Finger Lakes Where Retirees Are Moving To

More in Places