10 Best Places To Live In The Finger Lakes In 2025
Imagine taking your first juicy bite of a freshly picked Honeycrisp before strolling along a beautiful lakefront to a local eatery. On your way, you walk by a historic tavern that has been standing for over 100 years. At the restaurant, you order an aromatic white wine that was made less than a mile away. Sound dreamy? If you lived in one of the many charming small towns in the Finger Lakes, this relaxing afternoon could easily become a reality.
While it may seem like only a vacation spot, the Finger Lakes region in upstate New York continues to be a top choice for new residents seeking a high quality of life. The most difficult part is choosing which small town in the Finger Lakes offers the perfect blend of scenic surroundings, affordability, deeply-rooted history, educational opportunities, and distinct local vibes for you.
Skaneateles
Known as the "Jewel of the Finger Lakes," Skaneateles is situated on the shores of one of the cleanest lakes in the U.S. Residents enjoy boating, swimming, and lakeside relaxation in the pristine waters of Skaneateles Lake year-round (although jackets and sweaters will be necessary in winter!). The 19th-century colonial architecture along East Genesee Street, along with cultural landmarks like the Skaneateles Historical Society and the renowned Krebs Restaurant, allows residents to experience the deep roots of this lakeside town.
Median home values are over $500,000 and come with superb schools, a low crime rate, beautiful scenery, a tight-knit community, as well as a plethora of activities for people of all ages. The poverty rate is also lower than the national average of 11,1% at 7.2%. Residents can stay healthy and active at the Skaneateles Community Center, which boasts an ice arena, an aquatics center, and a gymnasium. Local events and activities such as the Dickens Christmas celebration and summer concerts at Clift Park keep residents busy all year long.
Ithaca
Ithaca, New York, home to Cornell University and Ithaca College, thrives with intellectual energy and diverse cultural events, with a backdrop of spectacular natural beauty. Along with culture, the town is affordable, boasting a median home value of around $330,000, about $150,000 less than the state average. As far as community and social services go, organizations such as The Finger Lakes Independence Center, Tompkins County Office for the Aging, and the Greater Ithaca Activities Center are there to support residents.
The pedestrian-friendly downtown area is filled with diverse local shops and restaurants, as well as stunning public art. One of the coolest and most unique features downtown is the Sagan Planet Walk—a scale model of the solar system that extends from downtown Ithaca Commons to the Sciencenter. When it comes to annual festivals, this place will not disappoint with the Ithaca Festival, the Apple Festival, the Finger Lakes International Dragon Boat Festival, and the Ithaca Brew Fest all taking place annually. For outdoor enthusiasts, Buttermilk Falls State Park and the Cascadilla Gorge Trail are both notable places for snapping pictures of cascading waterfalls or taking a peaceful walk through Mother Nature.
Canandaigua
At the northern tip of Canandaigua Lake in New York's Finger Lakes region is the harmonious and affordable town of Canandaigua. Median home values in the area are approximately $330,000, more financially accessible than homes in some of the surrounding towns. The town also has a VA Medical Center and an emergency center at the F.F. Thompson Hospital. Along with the financial benefits and accessible healthcare, Canandaigua doesn’t skimp on scenic attractions, historical ambiance, or learning opportunities, either.
The beautifully landscaped gardens at The Sonnenberg Gardens and Mansion State Historic Park is a wonderful place for residents to spend an afternoon before heading to The Granger Homestead and Carriage Museum. Visitors to the museum can learn more about 19th-century life in Canandaigua and see antique horse-drawn carriages. Want to learn something while dining? The New York Kitchen offers hands-on cooking classes and wine tastings for those who want a more interactive dining experience.
Geneva
Along the northern tip of Seneca Lake sits Geneva, an attractive place to call home for those seeking quality living without the hefty price tag. With median home values at $200,000, it offers a blend of affordability and recreational opportunities. For medical needs, Finger Lakes Health Center is nearby, offering both emergency care and assisted senior living not far from downtown. The Geneva Community Center is another fabulous resource just north of town that offers a variety of programs for the whole family.
History is immensely important to the residents of Geneva, and it’s easy for residents to become a part of the preservation efforts. A non-profit group called Historic Geneva, offers tours, exhibits, and educational programs related to the town’s past. The group carefully maintains several historic properties, including the Geneva History Museum and Rose Hill Mansion. Looking to spend some time in nature? Locals often head to Seneca Lake State Park for some outdoor fun.
Watkins Glen
Affordable, scenic, and rich in community spirit, Watkins Glen is a standout destination for those seeking a peaceful yet engaging place to live. With a median home value of around $210,000, it offers an accessible housing market compared to many nearby towns. New residents will also appreciate the town’s low violent crime rate, as the community only saw one violent crime in 2019, according to FBI data.
There’s no shortage of things to do in and around Watkins Glen. Local favorites like the Glen Dairy Bar and Seneca Cheese Company provide handmade treats. At the same time, the Watkins Glen Community Center regularly hosts farmers' markets and seasonal events that bring neighbors together. Nature lovers will feel right at home at Watkins Glen State Park, where a 400-foot-deep gorge and 19 waterfalls create one of the most scenic hikes in New York. Nearby, the Finger Lakes National Forest offers more than 30 miles of trails for outdoor enthusiasts of all experience levels.
Penn Yan
The village of Penn Yan is steeped in history, relatively inexpensive, and home to quirky local establishments. Penn Yan is a financially attractive location at the northern point of Keuka Lake with median home values around $300,000, over $150,000 less than New York’s average. In downtown Penn Yan, the Keuka Candy Emporium, known for its extensive selection of retro sweets, is a fun place to buy some treats, and the nearby Arts Center of Yates County supports regional artists. The Windmill Farm & Craft Market offers a unique shopping experience with tons of vendors selling crafts, handmade items, and produce from nearby farms.
After supporting small businesses and local artists, residents can enjoy some fresh air on the Keuka Lake Outlet Trail. In the event that a hospital is needed, Soldiers & Sailors Memorial Hospital is a top-notch institution that provides patients with exceptional care right in Penn Yan. With its amenities and activities, Penn Yan is a great destination for retirees, and over 26% of locals are over the age of 65.
Hammondsport
On the southern tip of Keuka Lake lies the town of Hammondsport, another excellent place to settle down. With a population of less than 1,000, getting to know your neighbors here is easy! Whatever their interests, residents of Hammondsport have no reason to be bored. The Fred & Harriet Memorial Library is near the lake, where locals can grab something to read before heading toward the water. In addition, swimming at Depot Park and boating on Keuka Lake are some popular choices for outdoor activities, while foodies and history enthusiasts can also stay busy.
Locals have tons of options when it comes to dining out. Vern’s Café, a great spot for a morning pastry, and the Waterfront Restaurant are some highly-rated favorites. Pairing wine tastings and panoramic lake views at either Dr. Konstantin Frank Winery or Bully Hill Vineyards is a must for any wine aficionado. All these amazing activities come at a steal as Hammondsport has a median home value of less than $320,000.
Aurora
On the eastern shore of Cayuga Lake is Aurora. This small village boasts a growing economy centered around local businesses, low crime and poverty rates, and highly rated schools. As far as activities go, Aurora offers the perfect combination of fun and relaxation for residents. Like other towns and villages in the Finger Lakes region, Aurora is close to vineyards and wineries. Cayuga Lake Wine Trail, the oldest of its kind in the country, is a great place to try a regional Riesling or Pinot Noir. Notable landmarks in the village include The Aurora Inn, a restored 1833 stagecoach stop, and the Spa at the Inns of Aurora, a nationally acclaimed wellness retreat. While this spa draws crowds from all over, residents of Aurora can enjoy their proximity to massages, energy work, hydrotherapy, and more all year long. With median home values at around $300,000, residents don’t have to feel guilty for treating themselves!
Trumansburg
Trumansburg, New York, is a charming village with many job opportunities and a low crime rate. According to FBI data, the town only had one incident of violent crime in 2019, so residents can rest assured about safety. With median home values at approximately $305,000, the town is also quite affordable.
In addition, the village has a variety of things to do. Love music? Locals enjoy concerts and take music lessons at the Trumansburg Conservatory of Fine Arts. You also can’t miss the annual Finger Lakes GrassRoots Festival of Music and Dance. Enjoy history? The Ulysses Historical Society Museum has you covered. Want to see a 215-foot waterfall? Head to Taughannock Falls State Park. Need a quiet stroll? It’s no wonder Travel and Leisure considers Trumansburg one of New York State’s best small towns.
Lansing
Lansing has so much to offer residents, including a low crime rate, easy access to Ithaca Tompkins International Airport, and excellent public schools. Not only do students receive a great education in the local elementary, middle, and high schools, but Lansing’s proximity to the universities in Ithaca makes higher education easily accessible as well. When the weather is nice, family outings and community events often take place at Myers Park, where residents can picnic, swim, and dock their boats in the marina. The Rogues' Harbor Inn, a landmark built in the 1830s, is a beautiful example of the Greek Revival style, of which Lansing residents are quite proud.
Final Thoughts
Small-town living doesn’t mean sacrificing quality of life, especially in the Finger Lakes. Families with children, retirees, and single people alike can all find a place they love here. A fresh start in one of these lakeside towns might be exactly what you need in 2025. Whether your interest is piqued by outdoor fun, unique local wines, beautiful natural scenery, seasonal festivals, or the history of upstate New York, the Finger Lakes will not disappoint.
