10 Safest Small Communities To Settle In The Poconos

Widely known for their forests, lakes, and year-round recreation, the Pocono Mountains region’s most excellent appeal lies in its small, safe communities. Beyond the resorts and seasonal crowds, the Poconos are home to towns and villages that deliver quiet living, access to nature, and a strong sense of local community. As they feature lower population density, these close-knit neighborhoods have crime rates that are well below state averages, particularly for violent offenses. Whether you are looking for a lakeside village, a rural township, or a family-oriented town, each of these communities offers a distinct lifestyle shaped by its natural features and local culture. This article highlights some Pocono-area communities that stand out for their balance of safety, lifestyle, and recreational opportunities. Each offers a range of options available to people seeking a peaceful place to settle down in while remaining connected to the natural beauty and amenities that define the Pocono region.

Lake Ariel

Lake Ariel is a quiet, lakeside community that offers a relaxed and neighborly atmosphere centered around outdoor living. The town is named after its namesake lake, and the area is particularly appealing to residents who enjoy water-based recreation, including fishing, paddleboarding, kayaking, and swimming. Foodies will enjoy the fresh, locally caught Trout in restaurants like Drafts Bar and Grill, or seasonal apple cider donuts at Ritter's Cider Mill. Summer months bring community events, picnics, fun at the Hideout Sports Complex, and a steady rhythm of seasonal life, while fall and winter offer Maple syrup at Maple Hill Farms and a return to a calm, domestic paradise.

With neighborhoods that are typically low-density and nestled among lush woods, Lake Ariel offers a strong sense of privacy and safety to its residents. Reported violent crime is low compared to state benchmarks, aligning with the experiences of long-term residents and local law enforcement. Lake Ariel is perfect for families, retirees, and second-home owners who value tranquility over nightlife or dense urban development. With surrounding forests, scenic views, and easy access to nearby Pocono towns for essentials, Lake Ariel offers a peaceful blend of nature, safety, and small-town living.

Lake Harmony

For over a century, Lake Harmony has been a haven for those seeking serene surroundings, crystal-clear mountain water, and natural beauty. Its rich history as the vast hunting and fishing grounds for the Lenape Native Americans long ago lives on in spots like Big Boulder Lake and Big Rock Traverse. Another hidden gem is Hawk Falls, a tucked-away waterfall that makes the half-mile hike worth every step.

The town itself is heartwarming and charming, with stores like the Terra Cottage Cafe and Gifts, a restaurant offering outdoor seating and lovely waterfront views. The neighboring gift shop offers a variety of interesting knick-knacks and memorabilia. Although primarily for tourists, Split Rock Resort offers days worth of entertainment, including an indoor waterpark, bowling, arcade games, and its own golf course. The area is secure and safe, with a low crime rate, making it an ideal place for families to put down roots.

Tannersville

Although Tannersville is best known as a gateway to Big Pocono State Park and some of the most popular resorts in the Poconos, it also boasts a quieter, community-focused residential side. The village benefits from year-round attractions, including the Camelbeach Waterpark and the Camelback Ski Area, which provide recreation, jobs, and entertainment for residents. Beyond the resorts and tourist attractions, Tannersville offers interesting shopping opportunities at the Pocono Premium Outlets and the local favorite Pocono Peddler's Village Antique Mall.

The town also boasts some mainstays, such as the family-friendly Smuggler's Cove restaurant. While tourism increases activity during peak seasons, residential neighborhoods are generally calm. They are known for a very low crime rate. The presence of nearby amenities means residents enjoy convenience without the need for long commutes. Tannersville is ideal for individuals and families who enjoy an active lifestyle and don’t mind a tourist presence, especially when it is in exchange for abundant recreation.

Honesdale

Honesdale is a classic county town with deep historical roots and a strong sense of civic pride. Set along the Lackawaxen River, it has small‑town charm with cultural and educational attractions mixed in as well. The Dorflinger Glass Museum is a treat for the eyes, showcasing the craftsmanship of the Dorflinger glass companies in Brooklyn, New York, and White Mills, Pennsylvania. As one of the first railway hubs, the Wayne County Historical Society has maintained a complete replica of the Stourbridge Lion, the first locomotive. Local museums also highlight the region’s industrial and railroad heritage.

The downtown area boasts a diverse mix of independent shops, bookstores, and cafés, creating a welcoming and cozy atmosphere. Honesdale Community Park also offers many paths that are perfect for a peaceful picnic and leisurely walks. Crime levels, particularly violent crime, are generally low and consistent with small-town norms, reinforced by community groups like the Cooperage Project bringing the community together to reinforces a sense of communal safety. Honesdale appeals to those who value community engagement, history, walkability, and a comfortable hub for both long‑time residents and newcomers to the northern Poconos.

Tobyhanna

Tobyhanna is a diverse and growing community located in the heart of the Poconos, offering suburban convenience with easy access to nature. Home to roughly 9,000 residents, the town benefits from a mix of long-time locals, including military families connected to the Tobyhanna Army Depot, as well as newer residents drawn by the town's family-friendly affordability. Tobyhanna State Park is the central attraction of the area, offering swimming, beaches, wooded hiking trails, and peaceful picnic areas that make outdoor recreation a daily part of life.

For hunters and fishers, there is State Game Lands Number 127, a vast, unspoiled natural area that offers incredible outdoor opportunities. In town, landmarks like Saint Anne’s Church give beautiful examples of the area's historical architecture. Tobyhanna’s neighborhoods are primarily residential and community-oriented, making it an appealing destination for families and retirees alike. With steady development, access to regional highways, and a reputation for security, safety, and low crime compared to larger urban centers, Tobyhanna remains a practical and comfortable choice for Pocono living.

Delaware Water Gap

Tucked away like a precious gemstone, Delaware Water Gap is a small borough defined by its magnificent natural surroundings and the outdoor lifestyle it offers. Located within the Delaware Water Gap National Recreation Area, the town provides direct access to hiking trails, river routes, and the Appalachian Trail. Canoeing, kayaking, and camping are integral to life here, attracting outdoor enthusiasts from around the area and the country year-round. Despite seasonal tourism, the permanent residential population is pretty small, leading to very low levels of resident‑related violent crime.

The town itself is quiet yet proud, boasting the charming Antoine Dutot Museum and Gallery, which showcases an array of exhibitions centered on the area’s rich cultural heritage. The magnificent and carefully preserved Historic Castle Inn also stands out, offering visitors the chance to step back in time to the early 1900s. Residents live and revel in the sense of tranquility, and having access to one of the most scenic landscapes in Pennsylvania is a great selling point as well. Delaware Water Gap is ideal for those who prioritize nature and recreation over urban convenience. Its combination of breathtaking scenery, minimal congestion, and safety makes it one of the most unique and peaceful places to live in the Poconos.

Milford

A charming historic borough in Pike County, Milford feels both ageless and welcoming. Its tree-lined streets, historically preserved architecture, and walkable downtown area give it a classic small-town character. Landmarks like Grey Towers National Historic Site and its French chateau-style mansion reflect the area’s cultural and conservation history. Local galleries and cafés support a vibrant arts scene, including the annual Milford Music Festival that draws music fans from throughout the region and beyond.

Outdoor recreation is easily accessible, with fabulous nearby trails that take residents to spots like Raymondskill Falls, the tallest waterfall in Pennsylvania, fishing spots, and forested areas offering year-round enjoyment. Milford’s size allows for a close-knit community, where local businesses and communal events play a vital role in the daily lives of residents. The town is known for its stable and low levels of serious crime, which adds to its appeal for families and retirees. Milford strikes a balance between tourism and residential calm, making it feel lively without being overwhelming.

Hawley

Known for its welcoming atmosphere and scenic beauty, Hawley is a picturesque small town nestled along the shores of Lake Wallenpaupack. This town blends the historic charm of buildings like the Ritz Company Playhouse with modern leisure, exemplified by the Country Club at Woodloch Springs and its spectacular 18-hole golf course. Hawley also offers the Wallenpaupack Brewing Company brewpub as a popular dining option, and for wine lovers, a visit to the Three Hammers Winery will not disappoint. A range of outdoor activities is available, complementing the numerous cultural attractions around town.

Riverfront paths and bike trails encourage relaxed exploration, while Harmony in the Woods offers a unique musical experience with live entertainment at the heart of the Pocono Mountains. Hawley hosts multiple seasonal festivals and community events that draw both residents and visitors, highlighting the strong sense of local pride prevalent here. While tourism brings activity during peak seasons, residential areas remain calm,family‑oriented, and with a high sense of civic responsibility; low crime rates are the norm.

Saylorsburg

Saylorsburg is a small, peaceful community that embodies the essence of rural Pocono living. With its low population density and residential appeal, the area is beautiful to those seeking quiet surroundings and a slower pace of life. Forested trails and parks offer opportunities for walking, picnicking, and enjoying nature at its finest. While Saylorsburg itself is modest in size, the surrounding lands have provided ideal soil and weather for cool-climate grape varieties.

This has led to it becoming one of eastern Pennsylvania’s best emerging wine-producing towns. There are several renowned wineries, including Sorrenti Family Estate, which features tasting rooms that offer wine sampling while providing stunning views of the local landscape. The limited commercial development contributes to a strong sense of privacy and safety, with serious crimes being rare. Local staples, such as the Blue Ridge Flea Market, keep residents connected, and the town's balance of seclusion and accessibility makes it well-suited for families, retirees, and remote workers who value calm environments and outdoor spaces.

Stroudsburg

This safe and lively town has a bit of everything the Poconos are famous for. In town, the historic downtown features the state-of-the-art Sherman Theater, where you can watch music and other performances. A walk around the Academy Hill Historic District features 180 structures that reflect the grand history of the town and hosts seasonal festivals and outdoor markets. Residents can whet their whistle at the innovative Banter’s Hard Cider or develop their palate with wines from Eagles Rest Cellars.

Outdoor enthusiasts will appreciate the work that the Pocono Heritage Land Trust has done to preserve their natural surroundings. At the same time, visits to the Kettle Creek Environmental Education Center offer in-depth nature workshops and guided walks. Fans of yesteryear will adore a visit to the Quiet Valley Living Historical Farm, which offers visitors a hands-on experience of pioneer life. Stroudsburg has a low crime rate and is an ideal place for families or individuals seeking a well-rounded community to call home.

Taken together, these Pocono-area communities offer a balance of safety, lifestyle, and access to nature that can coexist without sacrificing comfort or practicality. From lakeside neighborhoods and forested townships to larger municipalities, each location offers a distinct approach to small-community living. The smaller communities offer strong community ties, and an emphasis on outdoor recreation naturally contributes to reduced violent crime and a sense of security. For families, retirees, and individuals seeking a more tranquil alternative, these towns offer appealing long-term options. Even as interest in the Poconos continues to grow, these communities share a commitment to preserving the natural environment and maintaining livable, stable neighborhoods.